Monday, 14 June 2010

The strange hijack of the MV RIM

Mumbai, June 10 Radio Netherlands reported three days ago that Dutch naval technicians say now that the MV RIM has been so badly damaged that it is a wreck. The country’s HNLMS Johan de Witt, part of ‘Operation Atlanta’, had gone to the assistance of the RIM’s crew after the ship was abandoned ‘at the request of the Master’. The crew is to be taken to Djibouti.


There are hugely conflicting reports about the ownership, crew nationality, cargo- and seemingly everything else- of this vessel; we suspect that the truth, as in the Arctic Sea hijacked in Europe last year, will never be known. The mysterious 4800 tonne general cargo ship MV RIM was seized by pirates on February 2 in the Gulf of Aden while on a passage from Eriteria to presumably Yemen- and eventually destined for a scrap yard in India. Initial reports suggested she was inside the security corridor at the time; these were suspiciously contradicted later. There are persistent rumours that she was carrying weapons for Yemeni rebels at the time she was taken.

Ecoterra reported that the ship was “North-Korean-flagged, originally Libyan owned general cargo vessel” that had a Syrian crew. Radio Netherlands tells us now that the crew nationality is unknown, but they are ‘possibly Romanian’. The coalition ship USS PORTER confirmed that the RIM had been hijacked.

The ship is still shown in official records as owned by White Sea Shipping of Tripoli in Libya, while in reality it was allegedly sold to another company for her last voyage with a cargo of clay.



The ship was first taken by the Somalis to LasKorey off the Gulf of Aden where it was fired upon by Puntland forces. She then sailed around the tip of the Horn of Africa to Garacad, later being shifted to an anchorage 5 miles off Kulub. The pirates threatened

to kill the Master if a $3million ransom was not paid. This, for a ship carrying clay and bound for the scrap yard, is a ridiculously high ransom, and gives credence to those arms trafficking rumours.

This Hollywood potboiler does not end there, though. Ecoterra reported, early this month, that “During a serious shoot-out between two rival pirate groups surrounding the sea-jacked MV RIM, leaving 9 Somalis dead, the Syrian crew of the vessel managed to overpower six pirates on board and to sail free. Maritime observers working with ECOTERRA Intl. reported that the crew is said to be all right and that the six Somalis are kept on board as captives”.



Four days later, the crew abandoned the vessel at the “request” of the Master. Strange words to use. We always thought that abandoning a ship was on the Captain’s orders.



Given geopolitics, we also think that there is much more than meets the eye here. An ex Libyan, now North Korean ship is hijacked and held for four months. Crew are probably Syrian. Different pirate groups seem to battle over it, and, in fact, kill each other for it. The crew then mysteriously takes over the ship after “overpowering” armed men, later abandoning the vessel. A 4800 tonne piece of scrap carrying a cargo of clay commands a ransom demand of 3 million dollars. We also wonder if those Somalis allegedly held on board by the crew of the RIM abandoned it as well, whether they were ‘requested’ to do so, and what tales they may have to tell.

The story sounds fantastic even without the North Korean, Libyan or Syrian connections. With those- and Chinese proximity to North Korea- in the mix, the tale becomes almost sinister.
.

.

Thursday, 3 June 2010

Government approves Marine Casualty Investigation Cell.

The Union Minister of Shipping, Shri G. K. Vasan, has, in written reply to a question in the Lok Sabha, revealed that the Government of India has approved the establishment of the Indian Marine Casualty Investigation Cell (IMCIC). The objective of the Cell is to undertake investigation into marine casualties, such as groundings, sinking, or collision of vessels or death or grievous injury or missing reports of seafarers.


The Shipping Ministry says that the prime function of the cell will be to conduct investigation into the causes of casualty and incidents in accordance with the provisions of the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958. To do this, it intends to keep the mandatory doctrines enshrined by the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) in mind, as they affect casualty investigation. It is believed that the Ministry wants to keep in line with international standards and practices detailed by the IMO as they pertain to any safety investigation into a marine casualty or marine incident. The IMCIC will see the formation of six new posts, including a deputy head and accident investigator, says the Shipping Ministry.

The Cell would be empowered to:

(i) Conduct investigation into causes of shipping casualties.

(ii) Co-opt experts for the conduct of casualty investigation.

(iii) Depute persons within and outside the country for casualty investigation and other related matters.

(iv) Publish reports of finding of casualty investigation in so far as its causes are concerned.

(v) Participate in national and international forum for investigation of marine accident related matters.



Some in the industry remain sceptical about the Government’s motives in settling this longstanding demand. "Better late than never," said a port professional from Mumbai, quoted in a leading mainstream newspaper. A faculty with the Indian Maritime University in Mumbai added, on condition of anonymity, "It would depend on the kind of people getting posted to the newly created posts. They should ideally know shipping laws and practice. Look at DG Shipping itself. As an administrative department, its commercial side is weak compared to its nautical side. Not only is the department is understaffed, but it is finding difficult to get the right people."

Marine incidents in India often see huge investigative delays. "Our experience has been that it takes more than 10 to 12 years to complete an investigation," says an observer. "There is no sense in delayed judgments, but what makes one sad is that they rarely get implemented. The DGS is sitting on some of the important judgements which have been pronounced nearly a year back. The year before last there were about half-a-dozen marine accidents, but no one knows what happened to the investigations made into them," he said.

"Decisions should be made quickly to have any meaning. Take the case of the oil spill in the US. They have acted on it instantly. Litigations, if any, are taken at a later date. Investigations should be completed within a short time frame and should be made public."

We hope that the Government is listening to these experienced voices.
.

.

Saturday, 22 May 2010

Youngest round the world sailor returns home

Sixteen year-old Jessica Watson returned home after a 210 day, 23000 miles solo around the world voyage at sea to become an instant heroine, earlier criticism mostly forgotten. Australia came out to welcome Jessica and her boat “Ella’s Pink Lady” back into Sydney harbour in droves; media helicopters buzzed overhead, people had filled up beaches, Sydney’s waterfront and the Opera House. There was even a sky-writing plane that wrote ‘Jessica’ across the sky. Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Premier Kristina Keneally came out to receive Jessica, even as she was delayed by two hours struggling with a torn mainsail and heavy swell. The Prime Minister hailed her as the country's "newest hero".

The 16-year-old became the youngest person ever to sail solo around the world. Jessica is still too young to buy the champagne that was popped to herald her record; in any case, all that the tired but overwhelmed teenager wanted to do was sink into a "big, non-rolling bed and eat some fresh food". Her parents helped Jessica as she disembarked, a little wobbly at the knees. "As a little girl, people don't think you're capable of these things, they don't realise what young people, 16-year-olds and girls are capable of. But it's amazing what you can do," said the girl who has yet to finish school- and is looking forward to getting her driver’s license!

There is still some saying that the record is not official. For one, they say, Jessica did not sail enough to the north of the equator, as the World Speed Sailing Record Council indicates, to make this a true round-the-world voyage. The Council had withdrawn the ‘under 18 category’ after worldwide criticism and controversy about young teenage sailors being exposed to risks at sea.

To most Australians, however, Jessica is the real thing. Jessica is not fazed by all the controversy either. "Call me immature, but I've actually been having a bit of a giggle over the whole thing. If I haven't been sailing around the world, then it beats me what I've been doing out here all this time!" she wrote in a blog when at sea. She also said that she was overwhelmed by the welcome in Sydney, and that it was a "mega mega under-exaggeration" to describe her return as "the most amazing day". Among the highlights of her trip, she said, was the sighting of a blue whale.

Jessica has been sailing since she was eight, but she ran into a lot of criticism, as did her parents, when she sailed out of Sydney Harbour last year. Many said she was too young; many were concerned about her safety, especially after she had collided with a ship on a practice run earlier. Nevertheless, she embarked on a remarkable voyage through the South Pacific, across the equator, south to Cape Horn, across the Atlantic Ocean to the Cape of Good Hope, then through the Indian Ocean and around southern Australia.

The teenager is now a celebrity. A book, True Spirit: The Aussie Girl who Took on the World, is to be published later this year, and some are already calling for Watsons Bay, the last bay she saw as she left Sydney on October 17 last year, to be renamed ‘Watson’s Bay'. At that time, there were only a handful of spectators who had come to see her off.
.

.

Monday, 17 May 2010

Cruise Control

The port of Kochi has withdrawn the discount it was offering cruise ships, says Livemint; the report says that even though Kochi hosted a record 44 ships in the last financial year, making it India’s largest cruise hub, the port submitted to the Tariff Authority for Major Ports that there “wasn’t much demand for cruise ships”. “There is no steady growth in cruise traffic as well as vessel related income for the last three years due to concessional vessel related charges for cruise vessels,” the port told the regulator. “Hence, the concession is being withdrawn.”


The 33 percent discount the port was offering earlier had not stopped operators grumbling about charges. Louis Cruise Lines had stopped using Kochi as its homeport three months ago saying that costs were too high. Louis Cruise was paying around $73,000 every week to Kochi port, a senior official told Livemint, when its cruise vessel, the MV Aquamarine, used to stay there for about 15 hours a week.

The Aquamarine sails from Kochi to Colombo, Sri Lanka and the Maldives for an “unparalleled discovery of the aquamarine waters off the coast of Sri Lanka and the idyllic island of Maldives”, the company claims. It has a passenger capacity of 1200 and boasts of 525 suites, four bars, an outdoor pool and a casino, besides the usual facilities guests have come to expect from Louis Cruise, the fifth largest cruise ship operator in the world. Rumours are that she was even modified to include a cricket pitch for Indian clientele!

Observers say that many cruise companies are now finding the infrastructure and charges at many Indian ports to be a handicap to the kind of operations that they are used to elsewhere. The industry hardly had off the blocks in India two years ago, after easing of Central Government policies that problems first surfaced in Mumbai and Goa, resulting in a withdrawal of services by operators. Amongst other reasons, cruise ships were being docked at the coal terminal in Murmagao. “It’s like standing in a coal mine,” an executive for a cruise line had said then.

The Central Government’s attempts to promote the cruise industry in India will be ill served by such decisions. It has been just a year since the government allowed foreign ships to carry passengers between Indian ports without a licence. There have not been too many takers there, for reasons already mentioned. Kochi, really, is the only bright spot left for the industry in India. Let us hope that this move will not materially affect its lustre.

Friday, 14 May 2010

Industry Snapshots

Russians selling cruise missile systems in freight containers, according to media reports. The Club K Missile system is housed in a forty foot freight container says Concern orinformsystem-Agat, the marketing company selling the deadly weapon. The container looks like a normal FEU from the outside, but it houses four deadly missiles that can be launched from anywhere- ship, lorry, truck and train included.


The manufacturer of the missile system, Novator, has apparently shown a dramatic movie at the Defence Services Asia exhibition in Malaysia, where Club-K containers on ships, trucks and trains are used to attack enemy installations with cruise missiles. Iran and Venezuela have reportedly shown interest in the system, a move that has the Americans worried.

Observers are also concerned that the missile system will push the envelope in weapons infiltration and proliferation. Security concerns are quite a separate and equally compelling matter, since detection is extremely difficult. Reuben Johnson, a defence consultant, says, ‘You cannot readily identify what's being used as a launcher because it's very carefully disguised. Someone could sail off your shore looking innocuous then the next minute big explosions are going off at your military installations.'

The Club K will enable commercial ships to attack naval vessels or hit land targets. IHS Jane's Defence Weekly analyst Robert Hewson described the product as an “unwelcome” development to Fairplay. “Containerising a missile in such an overt/covert way, I don’t think anyone has done this before,” he said. “Why does someone want a strategic weapon that can be hidden in a container?”



Indian Government supports Indian shipping by giving first preference to Indian bottoms. “It is proposed in the draft action plan, that to promote Indian shipbuilding sector, we may give the first right of refusal to Indian-built, Indian-flagged vessels and second right of refusal may be given to the other Indian-flagged vessels,” R.K. Sen, assistant director in the shipbuilding and repair division of the ministry of shipping, wrote in a recent circular inviting comments from DGS, as reported by LiveMint.

This means that public sector companies like ONGC, BPCL et al may be the first to support Indian built or flagged vessels. Mint reports that this may be a short in the arm for private shipyards like ABG, Bharati, Larsen and Toubro and Pipavav, as presumably more ships will be built in India.

However, the newspaper quotes a shipping company executive apparently opposing the move, saying that “Indian shipyards are still not up to the standards of international shipyards and could not cater to the requirements of Indian demand. It will take at least 10-15 years for Indian ship makers to reach global standards”.

Other industry watchers say that the government’s move is overdue, and that India needs to support the sector in the same way as the Chinese do, with easy credit and logistical support for the maritime and shipbuilding industry. Others say that the Indian government, which had announced plans of divestment in the Cochin shipyard, may be looking at boosting the sector for better valuations before divestment.